Advisor-bar

Siri-ously? Can we find a decent voice assistant for Android?

Posted November 30, 2011 4:30pm by Marty Gabel Tags: Siri, Google, Android, voice

Apps mentioned:

Siri voice assistant alternatives are being marketed to Android devices with alarming regularity. Since the Siri technology was first embedded into iOS 5 on the new iPhone 4S (even though a Siri app had been available for some time), a number of Android developers have brought similar apps to Android. There’s also been a number of voice assistant apps that have been available for quite a while.

Google’s Android OS already has built-in voice commands. It may not be as personalized or sophisticated as Siri, or have captured the public’s imagination, but the technology has been around for a while. It can do things like search, call people, send text messages and so on. Still, it is a little devoid of personality and not always 100 percent accurate. So how do some of the new (and old) Siri alternatives for Android shape-up?

Does Cluzee have a clue?

Just released this week was Cluzee, which received one major media shout-out, but is being ridiculed by actual users. BGR wrote about this app, claiming it to be Siri’s first real competition. “We’ve spent the past day testing the app and it has worked quite well for us so far,” wrote Zach Epstein. “The scope of available commands is far more narrow that Siri’s, but there is plenty of functionality in this first public build of the app and we have high hopes for future versions.”

Opinion within the Android Market, however, is much more critical. With just an average two-star rating from over 600 so far (including over 350 one-star rankings), clearly many Android users aren’t so convinced. Many user reviews claim that there’s definitely some potential here, but constant force-close problems and instability issues are evidently hampering things a bit. A Siri-killer it most certainly isn’t, but perhaps with a few more updates, things will get better.

The Skyvi’s the limit

There’s also Skyvi, and so far, this has been received a bit more positively. It’s certainly not perfect, but is at least respectable. One thing that is interesting is that a lot of folks seem to be having fun with Skyvi. The results aren’t always right, but heck, at least they’re getting a laugh or two out of it. Once again, it doesn’t appear to be quite as competent as Siri yet, but it’s still a viable alternative for Android users to to download for free.

Tried and tested

It’s encouraging to see some Siri-like apps making their way to Android. The thing is, for a while now, Android already had a bunch of decent voice-assistant apps prior to Siri stealing all the headlines. For example, Vlingo Voice Assistant has been out for well over a year, garnered over a million downloads already, and has an average of 4.3 stars from almost 30,000 reviews. If that isn’t proof that Android already has some great voice assistant apps, I’m not sure what is. Vlingo lets you call people, send SMS or email, voice dial, search the web, find local restaurants and much more. It’s always getting updated and continues to improve. Plus, you don’t need a brand new iPhone 4S to use it. Sure, it might not be as pretty or have the ‘cool factor’ of Siri, but if it gets the job done, that’s good enough.

There’s also Speaktoit Assistant, featuring a lovely buddy who will answer your questions or perform various tasks like finding information or launching applications. It doesn’t seem as popular in terms of downloads as Vlingo, but it has been well received and garnered some good reviews. Once again, there’s a ‘fun’ element here and it has a personalized feel that matches Siri somewhat.

So for now, maybe it’s better for Android users to steer away from some of the more recent Siri clones which are clearly trying to cash-in on the iOS assistant’s popularity, and stick to some of the apps which have already proven successful and are often updated. If you don’t like one, there’s probably another one you can download instead, and perhaps within a few months even Cluzee will match the functionality of its peers.

Whichever way you look it, Android users are siri-ously (sorry) spoiled for choice for when it comes to free voice assistant apps.

spc_hicks09

922746715_july_3__2010_nory_055

Really? Sorry but this seems a little biased. Try to remember that SpeakToIt is only in Alpha stage and is almost right up there with Siri. The only thing it is lacking is the ability to continue a conversation on the same topic. SpeakToIt also has a website where you can suggest ideas and even volunteer to help with programming.

Reply to comment Posted November 30, 2011

hackerant

Missing

It's one of those things that haven't got much attention. Voice actions have been around for 20+ years (Windows phone anyone?). The point being Apple did a good job Siri-ously. However, they were 2 decades behind the ball weren't they? Now that they've rolled out Siri, over the next few months you will see a SURPLUS of apps come out for Android that will do the exact same thing, and a SURPLUS and VARIETY of STYLES of Android OS based handsets that will all do it the same and/or better. Thanks for the better implementation of a 20 year old technology Apple. Now we'll take it from here. Android FTW.

Reply to comment Posted November 30, 2011

azloty

Missing

I agree, voice control has been around for 20 years and hasn't gotten much attention... because it has never been very good. I use windows and mac, and voice control has been on both for nearly 20 years... it's been on the iPhone for years too... the news isn't that Siri is voice control, it's that it is really good Artificial Intelligence... and that is very hard to do. The story here is the same as iPhone vs. Android. Nuance bought Siri and Apple bought Siri from Nuance... Apple didn't make it... what they did do is recognize that the patents with siri are the best and it will be years before people can catch up to the same quality as siri and it will be nearly impossible to get that accuracy without violating patents... Hate Apple all you want because of their lack of technical innovation but their business is great because they do it right. They released the iPhone in march of 2007 and Android was released in October of 2008... nearly two years behind. Apple released the App store, then google, now this siri thing, no, it's not the first but that doesn't mean Apple didn't have it on the iPhone in 2008 it means you assume because you don't know, and you don't want to have buyers remorse for getting Android even though all the signs point Apple always coming out with the next best thing first. By the way do you know that Andy Rubin copied Java and Apple to make an iPhone and call it Android?

Reply to comment Posted December 01, 2011

Mexx

Missing

Sii-ously this voice control thing is very overblown. It was necessary for Apple to show something "magic" with poor 4s, and Siri was cheapest way. It,s nice thing but nothing more. Speaktoit is before Siri and now is more useful and work better worldwide. Take Siri and Speaktoit to Europe, Asia , Australia.....and try them both. Speaktoit is winner! Don't know how is in US.
Speaktoit guys was very happy when Apple come with Siri:) Apple know how to do marketing and whom to pay money to convince people that can not live without vioce-assistent, and as a result numbers of downloads of Speaktoit went to the sky:)

Reply to comment Posted November 30, 2011

martinlanny

Missing

andyforandroid.com has an app for android called Andy, which in my tests performed better than Cluzee, Vlingo, Jeannie and Speaktoit combined together. In fact, out of 25 different questions I've asked Andy, it answered 22, while Apple's Siri could only handle 11 of them. While it's still missing some features, I still highly recommend Andy over any of the solutions above.

Associated Apps:  Andy (Siri Alternative) - Free

Reply to comment Posted December 01, 2011

facerain79

Missing

There is Say Cheese Camera for voice controlling your camera.

Reply to comment Posted December 01, 2011
Facebook Activity